The protagonist is summoned to the village of Weirdwood and immediately gets entangled in its problems, helping the locals with goblin infestations, bandit raids, and missing persons. He meets the priestess Ziva, who tasks him with restoring a temple of Qetesh, a key objective that introduces him to other women who will join the temple and become potential mates. The central conflict expands with the emergence of a militant order of Purifiers who seek to destroy the portals connected to the supernatural realm. A significant portion of the plot is devoted to the protagonist's relationships, particularly with Erevi, a dark elf sorceress. The overarching narrative focuses on the growing threat of Nergal, the god of the underworld, who seeks to enter the mortal realm. The protagonist and his female allies must defend against Nergal's minions, culminating in a battle where he learns he is the "chosen one" destined to father many children to empower Qetesh and defeat Nergal. Upon securing a marriage with Erevi and uniting the various factions, the protagonist defeats Nergal and assumes the role of Lord Protector, dedicating his life to protecting his growing family and the realm.

The central narrative path focuses on the high elf Erevi, who is a sorceress and priestess. She helps the protagonist understand his role in the conflict with Nergal. The emotional conflict is her struggle with the curse placed upon her by Nergal, forcing her to serve him, which conflicts with her growing love for the protagonist and desire to be free. Her route leads to marriage, producing a child that is key to defeating Nergal, and securing her as the main partner in the final ending.

Ziva is the priestess of Qetesh who guides the protagonist in his duties. Her route involves restoring the temple, finding new converts, and dealing with her past. The core choice is to either help her secure the temple's future and strengthen her faith, leading to a final scene of her fully embracing her role as High Priestess, or neglecting the temple. A successful route results in a stable temple and her complete devotion.

Shakala is the ambitious goblin princess who seeks to unite the goblin tribes. Her route focuses on political intrigue and conquest among the goblins. The central conflict is her need to prove herself worthy as a leader while also managing her relationship with the protagonist. A successful route ends with her becoming Queen of the Goblins, uniting the tribes and providing a strong ally for the protagonist.

Alice is the innkeeper's daughter who is trapped by her father's strict control. Her route centers on her quest for freedom and a life away from her family. The core choice is helping her escape and find purpose at the temple. A successful ending sees her becoming a confident priestess and mother, free from her father's influence.

Victoria is the mayor's wife, a woman trapped in a loveless, political marriage. Her route is about secret affairs and political maneuvering. The core choice is to expose or conceal the Baroness's affair. A successful route results in her becoming the mayor, ending the oppressive taxes and granting the protagonist power and influence in the village.

Frida is a giantess seeking to find love and a home. Her route involves building a family and defending her home from threats. The core choice is to commit to her and build a large family. A successful route leads to a happy, family-focused life in Fridaheim with many children.