The protagonist, arrives at Elmwood University for his first day but experiences a sudden memory lapse, waking up in a stranger's bedroom during a FemSoc party wearing only his underwear. He is given the benefit of the doubt by the hosts, Katie and Taylor, and is allowed to stay. He immediately becomes entangled with the social scene, experiencing a series of sexual encounters with multiple women. His central mission becomes uncovering the truth behind his memory loss and how he ended up at the party. He begins meeting key figures, including his flatmates (Saki, Molly, and the twins Tasha and Ashley) and various members of the Gorillas and CheerSoc. As the weeks progress, he navigates his university courses under two vastly different professors, Dr. Riley and Dr. Novotná, and is elected as the course representative. He is drawn deeper into the conflict between FemSoc and the Gorillas, learning of the Gorillas' "Feminists Love Facials" campaign designed to humiliate Taylor and her society. Simultaneously, he begins building complex relationships with several of the female characters, exploring romantic and sexual dynamics with many of them. The narrative reaches a peak with a Halloween party hosted by the Gorillas, where he is subjected to a bizarre bone-throwing ritual and given an ultimatum by Tasha and Ashley to choose between casual sex and a serious relationship with them. His journey of self-discovery and social navigation culminates in him breaking into Dr. Novotná's office with his classmate Nina to steal an exam paper, an act that puts his academic career in jeopardy when his professor confronts him.

Saki's path is defined by a dynamic of power and corruption. The protagonist can choose to exploit her naive curiosity, slowly corrupting her from an innocent detective into a submissive partner. The emotional conflict centers on him manipulating her desire for knowledge and experience. Her route leads to a potential ending where she is either completely corrupted, becoming a willing submissive, or where he chooses to preserve her innocence, resulting in a more wholesome, albeit less intense, relationship. The final version of the game includes a specific ending for this path, often labeled the "Corruption" ending.

his is a dual-route where the player must choose to pursue a relationship with both twins simultaneously. The core conflict revolves around the protagonist's promiscuity vs. their desire for exclusivity. The pivotal choice occurs after the Halloween party, where they give him a choice: take a double blowjob and have things remain casual, or choose to cuddle and pursue a serious, romantic relationship with both of them. The "Cuddles" choice unlocks their true route, leading to a potential harem-style ending where they share him equally. The "Blowjob" choice locks the player out of this deep connection, resulting in a purely friends-with-benefits relationship.

Naomi's path is one of academic rivalry that turns romantic and eventually sexual. Her route explores her competitive nature and her eventual submissive desire to hear about the protagonist's other sexual experiences, developing a cuckquean fetish. The key choices involve how the protagonist treats her academic anxiety and whether he encourages her to embrace her submissive fantasies. A possible ending for this route involves her fully embracing her cuckquean role, while another, more wholesome path could see her overcoming her insecurities and establishing a more monogamous relationship.

The route to Taylor is slow and requires a specific set of actions that prove the protagonist's loyalty and integrity. He must side with her against the Gorillas, attend her events, and navigate her cold exterior. The emotional conflict is her deep-seated trust issues and her protective nature over her friends. The route culminates in a letter exchange and a formal date, but her path requires patience and a commitment to her values, often leading to a "romantic" ending where he earns her trust and affection, despite her initial reservations.

Katie's route is the most romantic and vanilla, centered on old-fashioned romance and emotional intimacy. The conflict involves her desire for a slow, traditional courtship vs. the protagonist's more casual and promiscuous approach. The pivotal moment is a picnic date where she shares her ideals of love, and the player must choose to be respectful and romantic to proceed. A successful route leads to cuddling, kissing, and deep emotional connection, potentially resulting in a happy, monogamous ending. The route can be "broken" if the protagonist is too sexually forward too quickly.